Save Huge on Direct Mail

Practical direct mail marketing resources

How to Track Responses From an EDDM Campaign

Every Door Direct Mail can introduce a business to households along selected postal routes. But printing and delivering a mailing are only the beginning. A useful campaign plan also explains how you will recognize a response, record the cost, and decide what to improve next time.

1. Decide what counts as a response

A response might be a phone call, a coupon redemption, a booked appointment, a form submission, or an in-store purchase. Choose the primary measurement before your mailing goes out. Otherwise, you may end up comparing numbers that represent different actions.

For example, a restaurant might count redeemed offers, while a home-service company might count qualified estimate requests. Track actual sales separately from inquiries so you can evaluate both interest and revenue.

2. Give the mailing a recognizable tracking method

Use a campaign-specific offer code, dedicated landing page, or clear question at checkout such as “Where did you hear about us?” A QR code can be useful, but it will not capture everyone who responds. Some customers will type your website address, call directly, or visit in person.

If you use a dedicated landing page, make sure it works on a phone and clearly explains the offer. Our direct mail landing page guide explains how to plan that experience.

3. Record the full campaign cost

Include printing, postage, design, preparation, and any distribution costs. Do not compare the printing price alone against the revenue generated by the campaign.

Use our campaign budget planning guide to organize the expenses before you calculate results.

4. Calculate response rate and cost per response

Response rate is the number of recorded responses divided by the number of pieces distributed, multiplied by 100. Cost per response is the total campaign cost divided by recorded responses.

Illustrative example: A business distributes 5,000 mailpieces, records 75 responses, and spends $2,000 in total. The response rate is 1.5%, and the cost per response is approximately $26.67. These figures illustrate the calculation; they are not a forecast or typical campaign result.

5. Try the response calculator

Enter your own numbers to see the arithmetic. The calculator runs in your browser and does not submit your entries to a server.

6. Keep a simple campaign worksheet

MeasurementWhat to record
Campaign datesMailing date and response measurement period
Postal routesRoutes selected and approximate households reached
Pieces distributedActual quantity mailed
Total costPrinting, postage, design, and other expenses
ResponsesCalls, redemptions, inquiries, or other defined actions
Customers acquiredResponses that became paying customers
RevenueRevenue attributable to the campaign where measurable
Lessons learnedOffer, audience, timing, or design improvements

7. Compare campaigns fairly

Use the same response definition and measurement period when comparing mailings. A campaign promoting a limited-time offer may behave differently from one promoting an ongoing service. Seasonality, postal routes, offer strength, and follow-up speed can also influence results.

When you test a new offer or design, change as few variables as practical so the comparison is easier to interpret. Avoid treating a small number of responses as proof that one version will always outperform another.

8. Plan the next mailing using what you learned

Review which responses became customers, which questions people asked, and whether the campaign generated enough contribution after costs to justify another test. Consider adjusting the offer, improving the landing page, or selecting a different postal route.

Explore available EDDM printing options, or visit the direct mail resource center for additional planning guides.

Compare two direct mail campaigns

Use this worksheet after two mailings have had comparable response measurement periods. Record actual results rather than estimates. Keep inquiries separate from paying customers.

Two-campaign comparison worksheet
Measurement Campaign A Campaign B
Mailing date________________
Offer or promotion________________
Postal routes________________
Pieces distributed________________
Total campaign cost________________
Recorded responses________________
Response rate________________
Cost per response________________
New paying customers________________
Cost per new customer________________
Contribution from new customers________________

How to complete the comparison

  1. Divide recorded responses by pieces distributed and multiply by 100 to calculate the response rate.
  2. Divide total campaign cost by recorded responses to calculate cost per response, when responses are greater than zero.
  3. Divide total campaign cost by new paying customers to calculate acquisition cost, when new customers are greater than zero.
  4. Estimate contribution using attributable revenue minus the variable costs of serving those customers. Compare that contribution with the full campaign cost.
  5. Write down differences in postal routes, offers, timing, and follow-up before deciding what may have influenced the results.

Important: A higher response rate does not always mean a more profitable campaign. Compare customer quality and contribution, not just inquiries. If a denominator is zero, record the corresponding rate or cost as not available rather than dividing by zero.

For planning a future campaign, use our EDDM break-even calculator to estimate the customer acquisition threshold before mailing.